Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Group Admins - What is the most frequent reason that you decline submissions? 

37%
50 deviants said Low quality
19%
26 deviants said Irrelevant subject matter
15%
20 deviants said Something else? Comment please!
11%
15 deviants said Submission to wrong gallery folder
10%
13 deviants said Wrong medium (eg photos submitted to a poetry group)
4%
6 deviants said Repetitive submissions (eg 3 photos from the same shoot)
2%
3 deviants said Regular submissions when only contest entries (for example) should be submitted
1%
1 deviant said More submissions by the same person as allowed (you can fix this yourself!)

Devious Comments

:iconfmorgana:
fmorgana Featured By Owner May 2, 2010
irrelevant subject matters AND when to the wrong folder. but when it's submitted to the wrong folder, usually one of the admin "invites" the piece back in the right folder this time and leave a note for the artist who submitted
Reply
:iconkelliroos:
KelliRoos Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010  Professional Traditional Artist
It amazes me how people want to submit photos to a traditional watercolor club :no:
Reply
:iconelandria:
Elandria Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010  Professional General Artist
Normally its purely down to people submitting stuff that doesn't fit the theme or the requirements of the group.
Reply
:icontouchedvenus:
TouchedVenus Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010  Professional Digital Artist
In the groups I run, I've honestly not had any reason to decline yet, BUT that may because of how super specific the groups are. One is for my husband and I's webcomic which accepts all art done of the characters and even fan characters. The other group is an OC Challenge that only accepts entries for each challenge.
Reply
:iconartbycher:
ArtByCher Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010   Traditional Artist
For my group it's about fallowing the rules on the submissions, which is pretty much what you stated...so it could be any :)
Reply
:iconlost-angle:
lost-angle Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010  Hobbyist General Artist
in the art based group I vote on submissions for, the reason I vote no is usually lower quality or repetitive (I've seen the piece submitted before or it's the same char over and over again in similar poses.
In the resources group I run, I vote no mostly because submissions are art not resources, on occasion I'll vote no when someone submits something that's almost the same as something that's in the gallery.
Reply
:iconsidneyeileen:
sidneyeileen Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010  Professional Traditional Artist
The most common reason is placement in the wrong category. In one of the groups where I am a Contributor there are too many submissions to move by hand. In one of the others, the submissions are so few that it's not a problem to hand-move them. In the third group I avoid the problem altogether by only have the "Featured" and a "Tutorials" category, because none of the members cared if the submissions were categorized.

The second most common reason (again, the Contributor group) is multiple submissions of the same item. I will usually accept one view and comment on one of the declined submissions suggesting thumbnails in the Comments section.

Thankfully, none of the groups I admin are particularly concerned with quality. Instead we have special categories for Tutorials, and encourage members to work to improve their skills.
Reply
:iconnitchwarmer:
nitchwarmer Featured By Owner Apr 22, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I chose irrelevant subject matter. If it does not coincide with the focus of the group, it will be rejected. I guess Christine and I agree on something.
:turbopoke:
Reply
:iconsomastardust:
somastardust Featured By Owner Apr 22, 2010  Professional General Artist
LOW QUALITY.
and i have really high standards.
i'd be a tyrant if i had my own group :giggle:
Reply
:iconnewdawnfades:
newdawnfades Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010   Artisan Crafter
Their Damn personal taste...NOT What the group subject IS!! :p Sorry to Rant!
Reply
:iconcinestress:
Cinestress Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010  Professional Filmographer
I get straight up animations instead of tutorials for animating in #theanimationsource even though I say we are only for tutorials and resources EVERYWHERE.
Reply
:icongwenavhyeuranastasia:
GwenavhyeurAnastasia Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
#DD-Catalogue has the most ridiculous problems. It explicitly states that we are only there to catalogue Daily Deviations, yet people without them still submit, and some even argue about it.
Reply
:icontylersangel:
TylersAngel Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
low quality,wrong theme.....to post a colour photo to :iconblackwhitephotos: is........:puke:
Reply
:icontylersangel:
TylersAngel Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
...or a photo of a woman....doesn't fit to a group called MENphotos :iconmenphotos:
Reply
:iconfreespiritfotography:
FreeSpiritFotography Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010  Hobbyist Photographer
For me it's either irrelevant subject matter and/or because it goes against group guidelines. :bucktooth:
Reply
:iconmbloomer04:
mbloomer04 Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
when people submit as many of ther photo's as we allow a month to the gallery and then just flood our favourites with their photo's :|

favourites is for other people's work you appreciate! dont use it to make your own work seem better GRR :P
Reply
:icondestroyinc:
destroyinc Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
Low quality. Most difficult and controversial also.

How do you tell people who's deviations quality is sub-par with them understanding it needs improvement. Some people just don't get it, and has been the most difficult thing to do. Its not that the subject matter is bad. Things like lighting, over-exposure, cropping, poor quality file (pixelated).
Reply
:iconkittywoodphotography:
kittywoodphotography Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010  Hobbyist Photographer
Low quality, wrong type of art, mulitple submissions from the same set are the main reasons I decline
Reply
:iconpullingcandy:
pullingcandy Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010  Hobbyist Photographer
I decline submissions when they are the wrong medium - grinds my gears when they don't read what the submission guidelines are :)
I also decline if they spam the same submission after rejection.
If the quality is low I remember I was once pretty fresh and usually won't decline for that reason.
I don't decline if it's submitted to the wrong folder, I move it manually.
Reply
:icondamaged927:
Damaged927 Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Generally it has to do with low quality. Things like their picture not being cropped to hide notebook binders, scans with pencil shavings on them, drawings that were scanned with a... cell phone camera (:bleh:) and so on.

We also assess the quality of a picture against their own galleries to see if effort was put in and/or if the picture looks finished. If we deem that it is not their best effort we will decline it, inform them as to why and give an example from their own gallery as to what we think is their best works :nod:
Reply
:iconartisnotanaccident:
ArtisnotanAccident Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010  Hobbyist General Artist
In :icongetdailydeviations: I look not only for quality, but also to see if they have submited their art in the right folder on DA (I don't want to see Darkroom work in photomaipulation fantasy). I'm also looking to see if they follow guidelines that the GMs are looking for. For example, has the artist of the deviation received a DD in the past 3 months, and if it's a photomanipulation, are they listing links to all of the stock used (not just writing personal stock used).
Reply
:iconthedaemonspawn:
thedaemonspawn Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
I chose irrelevant subject matter. If it does not coincide with the focus of the group, it will be rejected.
Reply
:iconnitchwarmer:
nitchwarmer Featured By Owner Apr 22, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I guess Christine and I agree on something.
:turbopoke:
Reply
:iconthedaemonspawn:
thedaemonspawn Featured By Owner Apr 23, 2010
Haha! Yes we do! :turbopoke:
Reply
:iconkneelingglory:
KneelingGlory Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2010
In #Critique-It, only artists seeking critique can put their work in our galleries. In order to submit to our galleries, they need to put a few comments in their artist's comments about what they'd like the critic to look at in their piece. People usually skip that and just submit their work like we're another place to get more views. >.< I had to completely wipe the member list to get the submissions fiasco under control.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History